We’ve all heard some version of this proverb:
For want of a nail, the shoe was lost.
For want of a shoe, the horse was lost.
For want of a horse, the rider was lost.
For want of a rider, the battle was lost.
For want of a battle, the kingdom was lost.
And all for the want of a horseshoe-nail.
Safety is not guaranteed. No one is more than a slip away from a cascade into catastrophe. This is a story about buttermilk biscuits. But first I have to tell you about Mushroom Joe.
Mushroom Joe is a mushroom purveyor in Seattle. His business was called Matsutake Joe, but he changed the name because no one knows what a matsutake is. As far as I could tell, the business had no digital footprint whatsoever. I inherited the account from one of my previous chefs. I never did ask where he learned about Joe. The “account” was really just a phone number. I texted my orders, and Joe responded exclusively in the form of hand signal emojis, always in the default Lego yellow, most often a handshake or forward-facing fistbump.
I suppose I should have asked more questions, but hey, he delivered good mushrooms at reasonable prices. The mushroom foraging business is secretive, so the off-the-grid vibe felt normal somehow. Joe and his wife drove a small sprinter van with a giant mushroom decal on the side. On one occasion, I swear I manifested him. It was a Friday afternoon in November, and I’d just realized I’d forgotten to order chanterelles for the weekend. Not five minutes later he sauntered through the door with a flat of chanterelles, asking if I needed any.
Joe walked with a faint limp and appeared to be in his sixties or early seventies. Over time he attained a somewhat mythical status amongst our staff. Whenever he walked through the door it felt like a good omen. Or maybe I just liked him.
Now you’re ready for the story. It takes place in a restaurant where I used to work, long before I met Mac. I was the sous chef, and our general manager had recently hired a new head chef.
Buttermilk biscuits are not delicate. There are five ingredients: flour, salt, baking powder, butter, and buttermilk. First make the dry mix. Then cut in cold, cubed butter until the mixture looks like wet sand. It’s fine to use a mixer or food processor for this part. Then add the buttermilk and bring the mixture together into a shaggy dough.
Here we reach a crossroads. Either spoon them out as drop biscuits, or roll out the dough for layered biscuits. I prefer the latter. I usually do six folds: roll out, fold in thirds, roll out a second time, fold in thirds, roll out a third time, and then portion cylinders with a ring mold. Brush the tops with melted butter and bake.
Biscuits and gravy was a star player on our brunch menu, so we made biscuits every weekend. For whatever reason, the new chef could not get them right. His biscuits came out weirdly flat and a little hard. In terms of customer satisfaction, this wasn’t much of a problem (luckily). There were two reasons for this: one, as sous chef, brunch was largely my responsibility (no one likes brunch service), so I made most of the biscuits. Two, we served them slathered in sausage gravy, so no matter what, the dish was tasty.
In terms of interpersonal dynamics, however, this was a problem. It was awkward. The line cooks were very amused, which did not help. I was neither amused nor affirmed. “What the hell is going on, chef?” was my ongoing thought. This was not an affirmation of my virtuosity. This was basic.
One Saturday morning, the entire kitchen staff was working, chef included. This was unusual, and I can’t remember why everyone was present. Chef had made the biscuits, and they were, as usual, weirdly flat and a little hard.
Around noon, just as service began to wind down, the front door swung open and in sauntered Mushroom Joe. I was confused because we rarely got deliveries on Saturday (I later confirmed that it was the other half of Thursday’s order, which he had forgotten). This was an open kitchen, with a clear view of the front door, so the whole kitchen stopped to watch. This was the first time his arrival felt ominous.
We kept the biscuits piled high on fancy trays so the customers could see them. Joe came up to the kitchen counter, set down his flat of mushrooms, then looked over at the biscuits. He paused to study them for a moment. Then he reached out and picked one up. This was a bold move, even for Joe. If it had been anyone else, I probably would have swatted their hand. Instead I froze in fascination. I was transfixed. We all were.
He held the biscuit up to the light like an archeologist inspecting an unknown object. “What is this…thin breakfast cookie?” he finally asked.
I closed my eyes slowly and deliberately, like storm doors against a typhoon, and pretty much choked myself to keep from laughing. To their credit, the rest of the kitchen held it together, too. No one made a sound. Actually the silence may have made it worse. I looked over at chef. He had turned to stone.
After a moment of tension that lasted eons, we snapped out of it. The cooks turned back to the line, and I quickly ushered Joe away from the biscuits so I could sign for the delivery. Joe went on his enchanted way and service concluded as though nothing had happened.
But something had happened. Chef never recovered from Joe’s indictment, that piercing arrow of clarity. A few weeks later he was fired. To be clear, his termination had nothing to do with biscuit quality, not directly anyway. His work performance deteriorated rapidly soon thereafter. He progressively stopped performing essential job functions like putting in orders, preparing food, or showing up to work at all.
After the fact, I found out that his family was falling apart, a bad divorce with a young child caught in the middle. That’s not an excuse, but still, you never know what’s going on beneath the surface. Well, maybe Joe does, but he’s almost certainly an oracle.
We’re glad you’re cooking with us.
Cheers,
Sten and Mac

